Double Checking Your Case

Directions: After your case is written, it will be your partner’s job to double check that your case is solid. Your partner will need to fill out this sheet in order to proceed with your case.  

Claim/Contention 1: 

Warrants: 

	What evidence supports this reason?

		Why is this evidence sufficient?

		Why is this evidence credible?

		Why is this evidence accurate?

Impact:
	
	What makes this reason relevant?

	What makes this reason effective?

Opponent’s potential rebuttal to this contention:

How will you refute their rebuttal?  

******************************************************************************
Claim/Contention 2: 

Warrants: 

	What evidence supports this reason?

		Why is this evidence sufficient?

		Why is this evidence credible?

		Why is this evidence accurate?

Claim/Contention 2, continued: 

Impact:
	
	What makes this reason relevant?

	What makes this reason effective?

Opponent’s potential rebuttal to this contention:

How will you refute their rebuttal?  

******************************************************************************

Claim/Contention 3: 

Warrants: 

	What evidence supports this reason?

		Why is this evidence sufficient?

		Why is this evidence credible?

		Why is this evidence accurate?

Impact:
	
	What makes this reason relevant?

	What makes this reason effective?

Opponent’s potential rebuttal to this contention:

How will you refute their rebuttal?